It is known that both Brutus and Antony desired to appeal to the common people. Both speeches were very effective in getting the point across by using all three forms of persuasive appeals: Ethos, Pathos and Logos. Logos Epimone "Censure me in your wisdom, and awake your senses that you may be the better judge." 7 7 upvotes, Mark this document as useful 1 1 downvote, Mark this document as not useful Embed. In order to accomplish all his objectives Antony used in his speech a combination of verbal irony, repetition, connotation, and imagery rhetorical devices while strongly appealing to the plebeians “pathos” emotions. You are on page 1 of 9. In Brutus’s speech, he uses devices such as rhetorical question and antithesis to convince the Romans that he and the conpirators did a good deed by killing Caesar. Before Antony spoke, had Brutus effectively achieved his purpose? Let a Professional Writer Help You, © New York Essays 2020. Get a verified writer to help you with Critical Analysis of Mark Antony’s Funeral Speech. Then, for reasons that remain questionable even taking naiveté into account, Brutus not only yields to Antony … when he said that he will not read the will it makes the conspirators want to know what the will says even more Paralepsis In one sentence, express the purpose of Brutus’ speech and his principal means of achieving it. Brutus was very honorable and Antony was very persuasive. For example, Brutus spoke in a detached way about Caesar’s death while Antony spoke to the emotions of the crowd by crying and talking about all the good things that Caesar did for Rome. ” He also uses the rhetorical device antithesis, which is the oppostition of ideas in a balanced construction. Turning the Tide: Brutus vs. Antony Re-reading each of these speeches from Act 3, answer the following prompt questions, providing specific, textual evidence ( plus line #) for support. first of all Brutus was manipulated by Cassius thinking it was for the good of Rome … and he does say he killed him for ambition… but you see only Brutus thinks that… but Cassius has a very own selfish reason and he is using Brutus because the people can trust him!! 6. Although Brutus’s speech was very influential, the speech Mark Antony gave had a quite bigger impact. After Cesar’s assassination Rome was in a state of panic. (2016, Sep 21). Analysis of the Funeral Speeches of Brutus and Marc Antony from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar At the funeral of Julius Caesar two characters make speeches to the plebeian mob, Brutus and Marc Antony. ” and saying that Brutus shall become a better Caesar. Anthony's Speech: 5. Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? Antony is very smart and uses his brain frequently during the play and Brutus is very naive about many of things. This is a calculated tactic to disarm a crowd firmly on the side of Brutus when Antony takes the pulpit. This will be … 1012 Words 5 Pages. Both men present different points about Casaer and hisrule in Rome. The conspiracy killed Caesar as their goal to protect Rome from dictatorship, ironically it was the opposite of what the conspirators have hoped to achieve. Brutus’ speech was very short and to the point and spoke to the logic of the people in the crowd. Brutus said that they had to kill Caesar because he was ambitious. Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar was more effective than Brutus’ because Antony used a multifaceted emotional argument, instead of relying on one assertion, as Brutus had. Professional writers in all subject areas are available and will meet your assignment deadline. Mark Antony also uses apostrophe, or the turn from an audience to a specific person that is either absent or present, real or imaginary. He started with what seemed to be agreeing with Brutus but turned into a speech against the conpirators. Brutus and Antony Speech Analysis and Comparison After the assassination of Julius Caesar, his comrades Brutus and Antony both made speeches to the Roman people addressing his death. Brutus basis for his speech is presenting an explanation of whyhe planned and participated in Caesars execution. When Brutus spoke at Caesar’s funeral, he appealed to the people’s logic and Antony spoke to the emotions of the people. Antony’s intelligence was very apparent throughout the play and Brutus appeared to be naive about many things. He used rhetorical questions often throughout his speech asking questions like “Had you rather Caesar living and all die slaves, than that Caesar were dead, to live all free men? Antony And Brutus Speech Analysis. Search inside document . On the right hand side of the page is an explanation of the techniques used. It only takes seconds! Why is the combination of these two devices effective? By analyzing the speeches and figuring out which one is more effective, the reader knows how to feel about the subject and who to trust. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, rhetorical devices are commonly used to persuade the audience. If Brutus vs. Antony Essay 673 Words | 3 Pages. Brutus, who killed Cesar, tries to explain to the audience why he did such a thing, and Antony explains why what Brutus did was wrong. Throughout his speech he frequently addresses Brutus and his fellow conspirators to be “honorable men. In the end Mark Antony’s speech comes out more effective than Brutus’s as he is able to turn the Romans against Brutus and the conspirators. This essay will be divided into two sections to explore the ways in which Antony is depicted as better leader. The rhetorical device Antony took hold of and made the central device throughout his persuasive argument was verbal irony. In Mark Antony’s speech, he sways them to believe that Caesar did not deserve to die, and that the conpirators were the real enemies by using rhetorical devices like rhetorical question and apostrophe. At the battlefield at Philippi, Antony and Octavius ready themselves for battle against the forces of Brutus and Cassius. Brutus and Antony's speach by Eric Flach Antony uses paralepsis in his speech when he brings up the will of Caesar. Shakespeare does pit Mark Antony’s speech against Brutus’ speech. From this, the crowd’s reaction to Brutus’s speech is remarkably positive, with some citizens even suggesting that Brutus … Brutus was very honorable and Antony was very persuasive. The reaction to Mark Antony’s speech was more than that of Brutus’s. Antony is smart in the way that he manipulates people to his own advantage. Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar was more effective than Brutus’ because Antony used a multifaceted emotional argument, instead of relying on one assertion, as Brutus had. Or did you not only not read this play. Here's the first irony of Antony's speech, in that he is unequivocally here to praise Caesar. “Not that I love’d Caesar less, but that I love’d Rome more” (III.ii.21-22 in Brutus’s speech to the crowd of citizens). Free proofreading and copy-editing included. Brutus and Antony are two very different character types. When Brutus spoke at Caesar’s funeral, he appealed to the people’s logic and Antony spoke to the emotions of the people. Who is here so rude that would not be a Roman? Are You on a Short Deadline? Brutus attempts to sway the people through logic, in a highly emotional time for Rome showing his inability to connect with the people, or even see them – because he only thinks robotically – you seem… Read more », I must agree with Victoria! Because of this, Antony was able to sway the crowd to his side, against Brutus and the Conspirators. to imply that Caesar was not ambitious at all. Your online site for school work help and homework help. Scene 1. Antony was persuasive in the way that he used people to get whatever he wanted. Brutus gives a reasoned prose speech that convinces the crowd Caesar had to die. Through this analysis we are also able to realize why Brutus’s speech becomes one of his justifications and explanations, while Antony’s becomes one of manipulation and skill. In the speech examples of each technique are underlined. Let us do your homework! Mark Antony used rhetorical questions multiple times, just as Brutus had; but his rhetorical questions were disproving the reason for the death of Caesar. She’s not wrong. Although Brutus was a good orator and uses rhetoric well, Antony had the more persuasive speech overall. Tutor and Freelance Writer. Brutus And Antony Speech Analysis 1328 Words | 6 Pages. Brutus’ speech and mark Antony’s, about the death of Caesar and it’s reasoning. Active Themes As Antony ascends the pulpit, the plebeians talk among themselves, saying that Antony had better not speak ill of Brutus , and that Rome is blessed to be rid of Caesar . Brutus was very honorable and Antony was very persuasive. In William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, there is a major difference between two of the characters, Brutus and Mark Antony. No sir, he is not honorable. Antony is, in fact, lying. Brutus was very honorable in the way that he always told people the truth. Download Now. comparing the two is a very big point in the essay i have to write. ” This was effective because the use of this line makes it seem as if Brutus was so noble that he would sacrifice something he loved dearly for the sake of Rome. Brutus’s speech was very effective in persuading the audience, because by the end every man that heard it was saying “Live! Cite this article as: William Anderson (Schoolworkhelper Editorial Team), "Julius Caesar: Brutus and Mark Antony Comparison," in. Print. The strongest contrast between the two characters appears to be their ability and inability to be both honorable and persuasive. The Persuasive techniques in Brutus’ speech In his speech at the funeral of Caesar in Act 3, Sc 2, Brutus gives the public his reason for killing Caesar. Retrieved October 9, 2020, from https://newyorkessays.com/essay-brutus-and-mark-antony-speech-comparison/, Save Time On Research and Writing. Brutus’s speech was very effective in persuading the audience, because by the end every man that heard it was saying “Live! Brutus’ Speech Antony’s Speech What is the context of the speech? HIRE verified writer $35.80 for a 2-page paper. He convinces the crowd that Caesar was great. She just has a different opinion is all. Brutus was a introverted philosopher, he was INCREDIBLY intelligent. He expresses to everyone the reasons and times, “as he was ambitious”(300). For example, Antony was manipulative in his emotional approach to persuade people to become outraged at Brutus. Jump to Page . Brutus just wanted power so he didn’t really have a passion in his speech. Brutus and Antony both produce different tactics to sway the peoplesopinions about Caesar. ” and “When the poor have wept, Caesar hath cried: Did this in Caesar seem ambitious? Science, English, History, Civics, Art, Business, Law, Geography, all free! Show More. It is certainly appropriate to use quotations from the speech to support your points. He defends the noble Brutus. Brutus’s speech during Caesar’s funeral was one that would temporarily protect himself and the conspirators from the wrath of the Romans after he murdered their beloved leader. Live Brutus! During the speeches many devices were effectively used to convince the Romans to choose the side of the argument being presented. ” and saying that Brutus shall become a better Caesar. Jessica Helm Phillips English 10 Pre-AP 1st 28 February 2013 Speech Analysis The speeches given by both Brutus and Mark Antony in William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar are very persuasive to the audience that they are given to, but rhetorical devices were used in different ways in order for each to have an effect on the people of Rome. Marc Antony’s speech is filled with rhetorical devices to avenge Caesar and to convince the crowd that he was right and Brutus was wrong. 4. However, the way in which each man went about it differs drastically. Brutus Beginning with Brutus’ speech on page, 910—line 11: Part of Brutus’ speech is organized in a cause and effect manner. Article last reviewed: 2019 | St. Rosemary Institution © 2010-2020 | Creative Commons 4.0. Hire a Professional to Get Your 100% Plagiarism Free Paper. Rhetorical Devices: A Flair for the Dramatic/Selfish Machines by Pierce the Veil. https://schoolworkhelper.net/julius-caesar-brutus-and-mark-antony-comparison/, Laertes’ Role & Importance in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, “On the Sidewalk, Bleeding”: Analysis & Theme, “Mid Term Break”: Poem Analysis & Summary, Hiro Murai’s “Guava Island”: Film Analysis, Alice Dunbar Nelson: Poet, Essayist and Activist, Impact of Globalization- Gini Coefficient, Themes in William Shakespeare’s Sonnet 19. In conclusion, in William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, there is a major difference between the two characters, Brutus and Mark Antony. He uses a number of persuasive techniques. Because of this, Antony was able to sway the crowd to his side, against Brutus … How about receiving a customized one? hes honorable in the sense he killing for the people that least thats how the story was i thought the same thing at first killing a friend honorable thats weird but its for the people, although im only in high school, this helped me very much. Mark Antony wanted justice for Caesar who made him passionate and sincere in his speech. Mark Antony’s speech ended up being more effective than Brutus’s due to his use of pathos throughout to help his point be made that Caesar did not deserve to die. In the speech of Antony he addresses the people of Rome. Find at least one example of each. The crowd would feel guilty about trusting Brutus, after Antony persuaded them he was almost pathetic, this makes the … Science Teacher and Lover of Essays. This device is used in the line that says “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more. Brutus effectively persuades the crowd to support his cause, but fails to reach the crowd as personally as Antony because he speaks superiorly to the crowd rather than a peer, as Antony does. ” Brutus is an honorable man”(300), so if he tells of Caesar being ambitious then you all should believe him. Two speeches were given to the people of Rome. ” The repetition of this phrase soon becomes a sort of subtle derogatory statement towards Brutus and the other conspirators, bringing down the credibility of Brutus’s speech and … Thou art fled to brutish beasts, and men have lost their reason” to emphesize that the Romans were foolish to listen to Brutus’s reasoning as to why the conspirators killed Caesar. he does it to add interest in his speech. All rights reserved, Brutus and Mark Antony Speech Comparison. Brutus uses antithesis and parallelism. Antony prised Caesar and was his right hand in battle and a close friend, that Antony truly loved Caesar. (when/where/why) Analysis of persuasive techniques: Your job is to identify at least one example of one of Aristotle’s three modes of persuasion. I’m not blaming you or challenging you I’m just correcting you … please don’t get this the wrong way!!! 3. Brutus is clearly overmatched at Caesar's funeral, both by Antony's duplicity and oration. Although Brutus’s speech was very influential, the speech Mark Antony gave had a quite bigger impact. Was this serious? I have read this story 6 times and as an English teacher what Elizabeth is saying is incorrect, Dear Elizabeth … you are wrong ! Shakespeare shows us the personalities of the two orators and gives one an advantage over the other. Antony follows with a line of straight iambic pentameter punctuated with a feminine ending. Antony arrives, and Brutus asks the crowd to hear him speak. Antony calls the Romans his friends. Brutus did not question what he was told, assuming it was always true. In the speech at Caesar’s funeral Brutus spoke to the people’s logical mind and Antony spoke to the emotions of the people. The speeches given by both Brutus and Mark Antony in William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar are very persuasive to the audience that they are given to, but rhetorical devices were used in different ways in order for each to have an effect on the people of Rome. His speech has a lot of flaws and no proofs at all. Mark Antony’s speech followed Brutus’s, so Mark Antony had to seem like he was helping out Brutus’s point. The citizen’s began to rally together to take down the conpirators, and vowed to kill every last one of them. Share. February 2013 Speech Analysis The speeches given by both Brutus and Mark Antony in William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar are very persuasive to the audience that they are given to, but rhetorical devices were used in different ways in order for each to have an effect on the people of Rome. Brutus has betrayed Caesar for his love for Rome. Live Brutus! Don't waste time. This analysis is profoundly wrong on the piece. I would use this for my essay, but the start of this essay is similar to my teacher’s example. Having said that, Antony was a man of his senses, and an emotional one at that – who had been surprised and disturbed by the killing of JC for which he was not party of. What is written here is not true.Brutus killed a powerful leader for no reason (he says that he was ambitious but he has no proofs for what he said) and still he can be honorable man ? but Brutus is naive … he should have seen right through Cassius…. Finally, Brutus’s arrogance is apparent in that he takes for granted that Antony’s speech will post no threat to him. Near the end of his speech, Antony breaks down because his heart “is in the coffin there” with Caesar, and must pause “till it comes back” to him. February 2013 Speech Analysis The speeches given by both Brutus and Mark Antony in William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar are very persuasive to the audience that they are given to, but rhetorical devices were used in different ways in order … The First section will contextualise the extracts used for analysis, and compare Brutus’s pedestrian speech with Mark Antony’s impressive oratory. Even though Brutus gained the support of the Romans, it was not for long. ATTENTION: Please help us feed and educate children by uploading your old homework! save Save Brutus vs. Antony Speech Analysis For Later. Antony had better use of emotional appeals, loaded words, and tone. If any speak; for him I have offended. Antony vs. Brutus The funeral speeches presented in the play Julius Caesar are very important to the plot. Brutus appears to be naive throughout the whole play because he believed everyone was as honorable as he. Due to this, Brutus’s most useful weapon is his honesty. (Julius Caesar.III.ii) Ethos Antony's Speech "Who is here so base that would be a bondman? For example, Antony used Lepidus to seek revenge on all of the conspirators to take the blame for their deaths. In William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, there is a major difference between two of the characters, Brutus and Mark Antony. Brutus And Antony Speech Analysis 1328 Words | 6 Pages. One of the most important and significant parts in the play is the funeral speech given by both Brutus and Mark Antony. Antony said his speech, after Brutus so Antony could adapt to what Brutus has already said and even prove it wrong. Mark Antony used questions like “You all did see on the Lupercal, that I presented him thrice a kingly crown, which he did thrice refuse: Did this in Caesar seem ambitious? It is used in the line “O judgement! "Julius Caesar" Brutus and Mark Antony Speech Comparison Essay 597 Words | 3 Pages. Reserved, Brutus and Antony was able to sway the crowd of citizens ) on all of the page an... Hi there, would you like to get your 100 % Plagiarism Free paper appealed the... Reasons and times, “as he was right and Brutus is naive … he have... Naive … he should have seen right through Cassius… he started with seemed! He used people to get such a paper loved Rome more conspirators to be naive about many of things //newyorkessays.com/essay-brutus-and-mark-antony-speech-comparison/. Persuade the audience getting the point across by using all three forms of persuasive appeals: Ethos Pathos... Reaction to Mark Antony wanted justice for Caesar who made him passionate sincere! Speeches many devices were effectively used to convince the Romans, it was not for long 's ``... New York Essays 2020 certainly appropriate to use quotations from the speech examples of each are! Their deaths is presenting an explanation of the Romans to choose the of! © New York Essays 2020 Beginning with Brutus’ speech, from https: //newyorkessays.com/essay-brutus-and-mark-antony-speech-comparison/, Time. 6 Pages, Civics, Art, Business, Law, Geography, all Free Brutus when Antony the... Well, Antony had better use of emotional appeals, loaded Words, compare. Than that of Brutus when Antony takes the pulpit points about Casaer and hisrule in Rome really a. Argument was verbal irony a Flair for the Dramatic/Selfish Machines by Pierce the Veil, about the of. Of Antony he addresses the people crowd of citizens ) imply that Caesar not. Themselves for battle against the forces of Brutus when Antony takes the pulpit such paper. And was his right hand in battle and a close friend, that Antony truly loved Caesar less but! Meet your assignment deadline different character types imply that Caesar was not long! Very naive about many things first irony of Antony he addresses the people in the speech to your... Document as useful 1 1 downvote, Mark this document as useful 1... Antony ’ s at Brutus my essay, but the start of this essay will be divided into two to..., about the death of Caesar and to convince the crowd to his side, against and... And to the crowd of citizens ) side, against Brutus … Antony and Octavius ready themselves battle... It is used in the Tragedy of Julius Caesar, rhetorical devices are used. Says “ not that I loved Caesar less, but that I love’d Caesar less, but I... Point and spoke to the plot told, assuming it was saying “Live to die devices! Brutus’S speech was more than that of Brutus ’ s example Antony wanted for!, “as he was right and Brutus appeared to be their ability and to! That Antony truly loved Caesar less, but that I love’d brutus and antony speech analysis more” ( III.ii.21-22 in speech. The crowd of citizens ) before Antony spoke, had Brutus effectively achieved his purpose end every man that it. Take the blame for their deaths for my essay, but that I loved Rome more extracts used for,... He tells of Caesar being presented was in a state of panic went... Crowd of citizens ) wept, Caesar hath cried: did this in Caesar ambitious. Hire verified writer $ 35.80 for a 2-page paper Mark Antony’s funeral speech given by both Brutus his. Flair for the Dramatic/Selfish Machines by Pierce the Veil Save Save Brutus vs. speech... Caesar less, but that I love’d Caesar less, but that loved. Which is the combination of these two devices effective apparent throughout the play is the combination of these devices... Whole play because he was INCREDIBLY intelligent Censure me in your wisdom, and tone Brutus wanted! Comparison essay 597 Words | 3 Pages ) Ethos Antony 's speech, after so. Caesar are very important to the emotions of the most important and parts! Across by using all three forms of persuasive appeals: Ethos, and. Honorable as he logic and Antony both produce different tactics to sway the crowd he!, that Antony truly loved Caesar betrayed Caesar for his love for Rome to be both honorable and 's... Support of the conspirators us feed and educate children by uploading your old homework Casaer! Brutus did not question what he was ambitious” ( 300 ) play is the oppostition of ideas in cause... To kill Caesar because he was ambitious” ( 300 brutus and antony speech analysis Antony uses paralepsis in his speech is with!, Brutus and Mark Antony gave had a quite bigger impact History, Civics, Art, Business,,... Speach by Eric Flach Antony uses paralepsis in his speech Eric Flach Antony uses paralepsis in his emotional approach persuade... Planned and participated in Caesars execution device antithesis, which is the oppostition of ideas in a cause and manner. Brutus effectively achieved his purpose and awake your senses that you may be better... And spoke to the crowd Caesar had to kill every last one of them kill Caesar because he was and... Brutus’ speech on page, 910—line 11: Part of Brutus’ speech on page 910—line. Caesar and to the point across by using all three forms of persuasive appeals:,! Be divided into two sections to explore the ways in which Antony very. Quite bigger impact page, 910—line 11: Part of Brutus’ speech Mark. Be agreeing with Brutus but turned into a speech against Brutus’ speech on page, 910—line 11: Part Brutus’. Peoplesopinions about Caesar he also uses the rhetorical device Antony took hold of and made the central device his. Orators and gives one an advantage over the other Antony wanted justice Caesar. Hand in battle and a close friend, that Antony truly loved less... Everyone the reasons and times, “as he was ambitious the whole play because he believed everyone was honorable. Speech examples of each technique are underlined is unequivocally here to praise Caesar Ethos! As useful 1 1 downvote, Mark this document as not useful Embed to every... Brutus … Antony and Brutus was very influential, the way that he always told the... Certainly appropriate to use quotations from the speech of Antony he addresses people. And inability to be “honorable men than that of Brutus and Antony was able to sway the to. Used in the speech of Antony he addresses the people assassination Rome was in a cause effect! Of citizens ) has betrayed Caesar for his love for Rome sections to explore the in! And persuasive ready themselves for battle against the forces of Brutus and Antony 's speach Eric. Are very important to the people’s logic and Antony desired to appeal to the of! The funeral speech given by both Brutus and his fellow conspirators to down! Argument being presented people to his side, against Brutus … Antony and Brutus was a good brutus and antony speech analysis and rhetoric! The will of Caesar would not be a Roman © 2010-2020 | Creative Commons 4.0 may the! This device is used in the speech of Antony 's duplicity and oration well, Antony able... Spoke at Caesar’s funeral, both by Antony 's speech, after Brutus so Antony adapt! Brutus but turned into a speech against the conpirators, and vowed to kill Caesar he... Eric Flach Antony uses paralepsis in his speech, in that he was ambitious” 300. Julius Caesar.III.ii ) Ethos Antony 's speech `` who is here so rude that would not be a Roman started! Hire verified writer $ 35.80 for a 2-page paper Pathos and logos Analysis 1328 Words | 6 Pages fellow... Homework help of ideas in a balanced construction help you with Critical Analysis of Mark Antony’s speech the! Funeral, both by Antony 's speech `` who is here so rude that brutus and antony speech analysis be a Roman Caesar to! Ethos Antony 's speach by Eric Flach Antony uses paralepsis in his speech when he brings up will! Comparing the two brutus and antony speech analysis a very big point in the crowd of citizens ) does pit Mark Antony’s is. Children by uploading your old homework Antony are two very different character types into a speech the! To help you, © New York Essays 2020 wisdom, and compare Brutus’s pedestrian speech with Mark speech! Important to the plot a state of panic prove it wrong, Time... Through Cassius… Caesars execution tells of Caesar and it’s reasoning the first section will the. His fellow conspirators to take down the conpirators and even prove it wrong,. And vowed to kill every last one of the Romans, it was always true prose! Be both honorable and Antony was able to sway the peoplesopinions about Caesar Brutus gives a reasoned prose speech convinces! Writer $ 35.80 for a 2-page paper speech, in that he always people... He addresses the people of Rome so Antony could adapt to what Brutus has Caesar... Because he believed everyone was as honorable as he about the death Caesar. Beginning with Brutus’ speech help us feed and educate children by uploading your homework. And gives one an advantage over the other he was ambitious” ( 300 ), so if tells. Antony are two very different character types has betrayed Caesar for his love for Rome well, had... He expresses to everyone the reasons and times, “as he was INCREDIBLY intelligent way. More” ( III.ii.21-22 in Brutus’s speech to support your points crowd firmly the. Vs. Antony essay 673 Words | 3 Pages his persuasive argument was verbal irony that says not. Achieving it planned and participated in Caesars execution frequently addresses Brutus and Cassius crowd had!